Standardising Tools to Improve Repairability

In an industrial context where reparability is becoming a strategic lever in product design, tool standardisation stands as a central pillar. Standard EN 45554 provides a rigorous methodological framework for assessing a product’s ability to be repaired, reused or upgraded, taking into account the tools required for each operation. Using standardised tools not only facilitates maintenance and refurbishment operations, but also reduces technical barriers for independent repairers, after-sales services and professional workshops.
The classification approach (from A to E) introduced by the standard allows for a graduated assessment based on the complexity of the tools required. By aiming for classes A to C — which correspond to accessible, commonly available or supplied tools — designers can mechanically improve the reparability score of their products, while aligning their practices with regulatory expectations (such as the Ecodesign Directive, CSRD, and the forthcoming Digital Product Passport). This also contributes to the economic viability of repair.
The objective of this article is to outline the tool-related requirements set out in EN 45554, explore associated design best practices, and illustrate how manufacturers can embed this logic from the earliest stages of product development.
The basic toolkit reference list
One of the key pillars in the assessment of reparability under standard EN 45554 is the recognition of a set of so-called “basic” tools, defined in Table A.3 of the standard. This standardised toolkit provides a common reference framework for designers, manufacturers and repairers, enabling an objective evaluation of whether a repair, reuse or upgrade operation can be carried out without undue constraint.
The listed tools are considered universally available, low-cost, non-proprietary, and do not require specialised training. They therefore represent the minimum requirement for a product to be classified as Class A within the tool-related reparability scale.
Selection of basic hand tools
Through Table A.3, standard EN 45554 provides a reference list of basic hand tools that can qualify a repair operation as Class A. These tools, selected for their accessibility and versatility, are typically found in both professional and domestic settings. Their use does not require expert skills or proprietary equipment. Examples include:
Standard screwdrivers: flathead, Phillips, Torx
Wrenches: Allen keys, combination wrenches, socket wrenches
Pliers: combination, needle-nose, diagonal cutting, adjustable
Cutting/leverage tools: utility knife, pry bar, hammer
Testing instruments: multimeter, voltage tester
Thermal tools: soldering iron, glue gun
Precision accessories: magnifying glass, tweezers
These tools are generally sufficient for disassembling, diagnosing or replacing standard components — provided that the product has been designed with reparability in mind.
Design best practices: drive types, sizes and safety
Reparability doesn’t depend solely on the use of a “standard” screw. What truly matters is a repairer’s ability to intervene quickly, without improvisation, and without damaging the product. Three key factors make the difference: the drive type, consistency of sizes, and the safety of the intervention.
1) Standardised drive types: avoid blockages and damaged screws
The choice of drive type directly affects disassembly quality. A common, robust drive type reduces cam-out, minimises the risk of damaged screw heads, and avoids the need for workaround tools (pliers, drilling, etc.). Below are some recommended best practices:
Favour a single dominant drive type across the product (e.g. Torx or hex)
Avoid using multiple drive types within the same disassembly sequence
Reserve tamper-resistant drive types for justified cases only (e.g. safety or compliance)
The goal? A repeatable disassembly process, achievable with standard tools and without incident.
2) Consistent sizes: reducing variability and speeding up access
A product becomes “difficult” to repair when it requires a collection of different screw sizes for just a few fasteners. Time is wasted, the wrong bit is used, and the risk of damage or incorrect reassembly increases. To reduce this complexity, you can:
Limit the number of screw sizes used (e.g. 1–2 lengths and 1–2 main diameters)
Standardise screws for the same function (e.g. housing, covers, modules)
Avoid screws that are too small or too fragile if they are intended for frequent removal
The goal? Fewer errors and more consistent repair times.
From basic tools to proprietary tools: a standardised classification
The European methodological standard for reparability assessment provides a framework for evaluating repairability based on the nature of the tools required. The simpler and more accessible the tools, the smoother the repair process; conversely, the need for specific tools reduces reparability.
Level 1: Disassembly using common tools or no tools at all
Level 2: Specialised tools that are commercially available
Level 3: More technical tools that are uncommon and not universal
Level 4: Proprietary tools restricted to the manufacturer
Level 5: Repair impossible even with tools
This classification helps assess the product objectively and guide the design process towards favourable levels (1 to 3).
Proprietary tools (when to use them... and how to avoid them)
A proprietary tool refers to a non-standard tool controlled by the manufacturer (e.g. a specific drive profile, custom jig, unlocking tool, or exclusive software procedure), with no accessible alternative available on the market. In most cases, it reduces reparability by restricting intervention to a limited network, increasing lead times and raising the overall cost of repair.
The use of a proprietary tool should therefore remain exceptional and be justified by objective constraints, such as:
Safety (high voltage, battery handling, thermal or mechanical risk)
Critical precision (calibration, fine adjustment, alignment)
Product integrity protection (avoiding irreversible damage during sensitive operations)
When a proprietary tool is genuinely essential, best practice is to reduce the access barrier by making the tool available (e.g. supplied with the spare part, available for loan or rental) and/or by ensuring repairers have access (clear procedure, availability, terms and conditions).
Where possible, proprietary tools should not be allowed to turn a 'possible' repair into a 'restricted' repair.
Design for Repair
The real lever for reparability lies upstream, in design choices. The key is to remain within Classes A to C, where repair is both technically and economically viable. Certain principles are therefore essential:
Facilitate access to components
Reduce fastener diversity
Standardise modules and replaceable parts
Document disassembly procedures (diagrams, videos, exploded views)
Fasteners & connectors: reusable screw (A) / removable screw (B)
Fasteners and connectors directly determine how easily a component can be removed – and therefore what type of tooling is required. The more standard, accessible and reversible the fastening, the more likely the intervention can be carried out with common tools. Conversely, as soon as an assembly becomes destructive or difficult to handle, repair will require more specialised tools – or may no longer be viable at all.
1) Screw fastenings: the most robust solution in terms of repairability
A screw-fastened joint using a common drive type (e.g. Torx / Phillips / hex) is generally:
Removable with a standard tool
Reassemblable without damaging the product
Suitable for repeated repairs (maintenance, replacement, diagnostics)
➡️ This is typically the most favourable scenario: simple tooling + repeatable intervention.
2) Clips and connectors: removable if the design prevents breakage
Clips, connectors and quick-release fasteners can be repair-friendly – provided they are:
Accessible (grippable, with space to manoeuvre)
Designed to open without excessive force
Identifiable (orientation, locking mechanism, keying features)
Otherwise, they quickly lead to improvisation (prying, clamping, forcing) → breakage and uncertain reassembly.
3) Bonding, moulding, crimping: the shift towards “special” tools
Non-reversible assemblies (e.g. structural adhesives, non-dismantlable moulded parts, crimping) often require:
Heating / cutting / solvents
Special separation tools
Destructive operations and reconditioning
➡️ Even if disassembly remains “possible”, it becomes time-consuming, risky, and difficult to reproduce — which significantly reduces actual reparability.
If accessing a part requires forcing, heating or destroying a fastener, the repair quickly goes beyond the scope of standard tools.
Dismantling depth: reduce tool changes
“Disassembly depth” refers to the number of elements that must be removed before reaching the part to be replaced. The greater the depth, the more fragile the repair becomes: more steps, more types of fasteners, more tool changes, and a higher risk of errors (missed screws, broken clips, incomplete reassembly).
In practice, a repair is not just longer — it becomes less predictable. And it is this variability that negatively affects both MTTR (Mean Time to Repair) and first-time fix rates.
Best practices to reduce complexity:
Provide direct access to critical components (e.g. dedicated hatches, covers, accessible modules)
Group removable parts into logical subassemblies (one module = one intervention)
Standardise fasteners along the entire access chain (same drive types, limited size range)
Avoid unnecessary “technical layers” (cosmetic covers, screens, non-functional intermediate parts)
Minimise upstream irreversible operations (gluing, destructive clips) that require separation tools
The goal? A faster, more repeatable intervention.
Environment & expertise: user / workshop / manufacturer
The type of tooling determines the required environment and the repairer's level of expertise:
Basic tool → home repair or light workshop, carried out by the user
Specialised tool → professional workshop, trained technician
Proprietary tool → repair typically carried out only by the manufacturer
Spare parts & interfaces: the tooling cascade effect
Having a spare part available is not enough. If its interface relies on a proprietary connector, difficult access or a destructive fastening method, it triggers a cascade: more steps, more tools, greater risk of damage — and sometimes, abandonment of the repair. For a part to be truly replaceable, its interface must be designed for repeatable removal and reinstallation using standard tools.
Typical example: a battery sold as a spare part, but glued to the chassis and accessible only after removing several layers. The part exists, but replacement requires heating, separation tools, and carries a risk of breakage → repair becomes restricted.
Measurable benefits of standardisation (Design Office / Workshop)
Standardising tooling is not only about “making repair possible”. It also acts on a key factor: repair process variability.
In a workshop, a repair always takes place in two stages:
1) Preparing the intervention
→ identifying which tools to take, checking that they are available, adapting the workstation, and making the operation safe.
2) Carrying out the repair
→ disassembling, accessing the part, replacing it, reassembling, and testing.
When the tools are common and familiar, preparation is almost immediate and execution is smooth.
Conversely, if the intervention requires a rare, specific or proprietary tool, friction is added:
time wasted searching for / ordering the tool
risk of using the wrong bit or handling it incorrectly
abandonment of the repair or return to the manufacturer
This is exactly what explains the following measurable gains:
Lower MTTR (Mean Time to Repair)
Overall time decreases because preparation, trial-and-error and “non-value-added” steps are reduced.Higher first-time fix (repair successful on the first attempt)
Standard tooling limits blockages and errors → fewer returns and fewer repeat repairs.Lower overall cost
Fewer specific tools to buy / manage, and above all less product downtime (which often costs more than the tool itself).Simplified training and documentation
Standard tools enable shorter, transferable procedures that are less dependent on a single expert.
A product that can be repaired with standard tools is repaired faster, more often, and by more actors, turning “theoretical” reparability into genuinely effective reparability.
MTTR & first-time fix: how to improve them through tooling
MTTR (Mean Time to Repair) and first-time fix (a successful repair at the first intervention) depend less on the “complexity of the fault” than on the smoothness of the repair process.
In a workshop, repair time is not limited to replacing the part: it is split into several blocks that quickly increase as soon as tooling becomes specific or uncertain.
1) Preparation time (before opening the product)
checking the tool list
finding the right bit / the right key
making the workstation safe (ESD, insulation, protective equipment)
➡️ If the tooling is standard, this time becomes almost negligible. Otherwise, it becomes a source of friction (and waiting).
2) Access time (disassembly down to the target part)
number of steps
tool changes
difficult access (deep screws, angles, obstacles)
➡️ Consistent tooling (same drive types, limited size range) significantly reduces access time.
3) “Non-productive” time (errors, rework, breakage)
unsuitable bit → damaged screw
unexpected tool → improvised disassembly
non-reversible fastening → breakage / damaged part
➡️ Standard, appropriate tools reduce incidents… and therefore rework.
This is exactly what improves both indicators:
MTTR ↓ : less preparation, fewer tool changes, fewer uncertainties
First-time fix ↑ : fewer errors, less re-disassembly, fewer workshop returns
👉 Conclusion: standardising tooling does not simply “save a few minutes”. It stabilises the repair process and reduces the main causes of drift (friction, uncertainty, rework).
Tooling cost vs downtime cost: the right trade-off
The true cost of a repair is not limited to the tooling. It also includes the time lost when the tool is not available.
Let’s take a simple case:
Standard tool available → repair completed within the day.
Proprietary tool unavailable → intervention postponed, workshop return, or after-sales return.
Even if the tool “costs” only a few tens of euros to produce, it can generate:
several days of downtime,
logistics costs (transport / rescheduling),
customer dissatisfaction,
and sometimes no repair at all (the product is replaced).
In this context, favouring standardised tools is a rational choice: it reduces uncertainty and lead times, and secures real reparability — not only theoretical reparability.
In design, the right question is not “how much does the tool cost?”, but how much does a repair that does not happen cost.
How‑to: designing to use standardised tools (10 key steps)
- Identify frequent maintenance operations.
- Analyse the access chain to components.
- Reduce fastener diversity.
- Choose fasteners compatible with basic tools.
- Ensure physical accessibility of screws/connectors.
- Limit tool changes in the design.
- Simulate a real-life intervention.
- Avoid proprietary tools — or provide them if necessary.
- Document the required tools precisely.
- Include tooling in design reviews.
Tooling FAQ
- What do we mean by “basic tools”?
Universal, accessible tools requiring no technical training (e.g. screwdrivers, pliers, multimeters). - How can proprietary tools be avoided?
Avoid exclusive fasteners and favour standard interfaces and fixings. - What is a “tool specific to a product group”?
A specialised tool that is commercially available, but not universal. - Why is tool-free access essential?
It lowers barriers to action, speeds up diagnostics, and prevents deadlocks.
Quick tooling glossary
- Basic tool: a common tool, guided by Table A.3.
- Product-group-specific tool: a non-universal but accessible tool.
- Proprietary tool: manufacturer-exclusive, difficult to access.
- Tooling class (A–E): a scale of repair accessibility.
- Disassembly depth: the number of steps required to access a part.
- Reusable fastening: assembly/disassembly without breakage or specific tools.
- Standardised drive type: a standard screw drive profile (Torx, Allen, etc.).
- MTTR: the average time required to complete a repair.
- First‑time fix: a repair successful on the first intervention.